Office environments face a mix of fire risks, from electrical equipment and wiring to paper, furniture, and flammable liquids, making the choice of fire extinguisher especially important. Foam vs CO2 Fire Extinguishers is a common comparison for businesses aiming to improve workplace safety without disrupting daily operations. In this article, we examine how each type performs in office settings, their advantages and limitations, and which option offers the best balance of safety, effectiveness, and convenience for modern offices.
Office Fire Risks
Different assets and materials fall under different fire classes, and knowing which applies to your environment ensures both safety and minimal damage during an emergency.
Class A (Ordinary Combustibles)
Fuels: Paper, cardboard, wooden furniture, textiles, curtains.
Risk Level: Class A fires are common in offices due to the sheer volume of combustible materials. These fires can spread quickly across desks, filing cabinets, and storage areas. Extinguishing Class A fires effectively requires an agent with a cooling and smothering effect, such as foam, which reduces the chance of re-ignition while protecting surrounding assets.
Class E / B (Electrical & Flammable Liquids)
Class E (Electrical): Fires caused by short circuits, overheating servers, overloaded sockets, or faulty wiring. These present a direct threat to business continuity, as damaged electronics can halt operations.
Class B (Flammable Liquids): Small quantities of solvents, cleaning agents, printer inks, or toners. Though generally low in volume, these materials are highly flammable and can intensify existing fires if not managed quickly.
Correctly identifying which materials are present allows offices to deploy the appropriate extinguisher, ensuring safety while minimizing asset damage.
Foam vs CO2 Fire Extinguishers
Foam Extinguishers
Foam extinguishers are a popular choice in offices due to their versatility in handling both solid and liquid fires. However, their effectiveness comes with critical limitations in environments rich with electrical equipment.
Mechanism: Cooling and Sealing
Foam extinguishers work through a dual action: the water content cools the burning material, while the foam forms a blanket over the fire, cutting off oxygen and suppressing flammable vapours. This combination helps to rapidly control and extinguish fires while reducing the chance of re-ignition.
Best Use in an Office: Foam excels in general office areas containing paper, recycling bins, and wooden furniture (Class A). It is also effective on small liquid fires (Class B), such as spilled cleaning solvents, making it a versatile option for non-electrical zones.
Pros for Office Use
-
Superior Class A Coverage: Quickly penetrates deep-seated fires and prevents re-ignition through its cooling effect.
-
Easy Cleanup Compared to Powder: The residue is primarily water and detergent-based, making it far less destructive than dry powder agents.
Cons for Office Use (The Dealbreaker)
-
Electrical Hazard (Class E): Foam is water-based and highly conductive. It must never be used on live electrical equipment, rendering it unsuitable for IT rooms, server racks, or printer stations.
-
Residue: Although less harmful than powder, foam can still damage paper files, upholstery, and other office assets.
In summary, foam extinguishers are highly effective for general office fires but must be strategically placed away from electrical assets to avoid catastrophic damage.
CO₂ (Carbon Dioxide) Extinguishers
CO₂ extinguishers are the go-to choice for protecting high-value electrical and IT assets in offices. Their non-contaminating, non-conductive properties make them ideal for areas where preserving electronics is a top priority.
Mechanism: Oxygen Displacement and Cooling
CO₂ extinguishers release liquid carbon dioxide that rapidly expands into a dense, freezing cloud of gas. This displaces oxygen, starving the fire, while the extreme cold provides localized cooling to suppress flames.
Best Use in an Office: CO₂ is essential around live electrical equipment, such as servers, PCs, printers, and switchboards, and can also handle small liquid fires like spilled flammable solvents.
Pros for Office Use (The Clean Agent)
-
Zero Residue: CO₂ dissipates harmlessly into the air, causing no damage to electronics—a major advantage over foam or powder agents.
-
Class E Safe: Non-conductive and specifically designed for live electrical equipment.
-
Class B Effective: Capable of controlling small flammable liquid fires.
Cons for Office Use
-
Poor Class A Coverage: Lacks the cooling effect; ordinary combustibles like paper and wood may reignite.
-
Safety Considerations: CO₂ displaces oxygen and can be dangerous in confined or unventilated spaces, requiring proper training.
-
Limited Reach: The gas cloud is effective only when directed close to the fire source, which can be challenging in larger office areas.
In essence, CO₂ extinguishers are the safest choice for IT-heavy zones, but offices must complement them with other agents to handle general solid combustibles effectively.
The Optimal Office Solution
In modern offices, fire risks are rarely isolated. Ordinary combustibles, flammable liquids, and sensitive electrical equipment coexist, creating a mixed-hazard environment. No single extinguisher can address all these threats effectively while protecting valuable assets.
Why You Need Both
A strategic combination of extinguishers ensures both safety and minimal property damage:
-
Foam Extinguishers: Ideal for general office areas, kitchens, and spaces with paper, furniture, or recycling bins (Class A/B). They provide rapid suppression and cooling for ordinary combustibles.
-
CO₂ Extinguishers: Essential for IT rooms, server racks, communication closets, and areas around main distribution boards (Class E/B). Their non-conductive, residue-free properties safeguard electronics while controlling small liquid fires.
By deploying each agent in its optimal zone, offices can maximize fire response efficiency and protect both people and critical business infrastructure.
KEBS and OHS Compliance in Kenya
Kenyan law under the Occupational Health and Safety (OHS) Act mandates that offices conduct fire risk assessments and provide suitable extinguishers for identified hazards. Key requirements include:
-
Equipment must carry the KEBS mark of quality, ensuring reliability and adherence to safety standards.
-
Extinguishers must be inspected and serviced annually to maintain effectiveness.
Implementing a dual-agent strategy not only enhances safety but also ensures full compliance with Kenyan regulatory standards, protecting both employees and business continuity.
Conclusion
In modern office environments, fire safety requires a strategic blend of agents. Foam extinguishers are ideal for general combustibles like paper, furniture, and kitchen spills, delivering rapid suppression and preventing re-ignition. CO₂ extinguishers, on the other hand, are the only safe choice for live electrical equipment, protecting servers, PCs, and communication systems from costly damage.
To safeguard both your people and your assets, ensure your office is fully protected, compliant, and prepared for any fire scenario. Contact Sidget Safety Kenya today for a tailored fire risk assessment and expert recommendations on extinguisher placement and selection.
